SBA Loan Charge-Off Rates by Franchise

Free to cite. Recomputed from the complete public record of SBA 7(a) lending, fiscal years 1992–2026. Free to quote with a link. Updated 24 August 2026: brand names normalised, see the correction note at the foot of this page.

Franchised businesses are no safer than independents. Across the full SBA 7(a) record, franchise loans charged off at 16.0% of resolved loans against 15.8% for independents. Effectively identical.

What varies enormously is the brand. Among brands with at least 400 resolved loans, charge-off rates run from 4.5% to 34.8% — a spread far wider than the franchise-versus-independent difference. Buying into a brand does not reduce your risk. Choosing the right brand does.

Charge-off rates by franchise brand

Minimum 400 resolved loans per brand. A resolved loan is one that has either been paid in full or charged off; loans still outstanding are excluded.

BrandResolved loansCharge-off rate
Matco Tools63234.8%
Cold Stone Creamery82233.9%
Blimpie52130.7%
Quiznos2,21028.1%
Fantastic Sams43422.4%
Curves for Women41918.9%
Baskin-Robbins43017.4%
Ace Hardware57513.4%
Mail Boxes Etc.1,11012.2%
Anytime Fitness80111.7%
Super 8 Motel51811.6%
Days Inn72411.2%
Firehouse Subs45811.1%
Dairy Queen1,01810.7%
Domino’s Pizza73810.7%
Massage Envy4728.5%
Dunkin’ Donuts9617.8%
The UPS Store6186.8%
Servpro5676.5%
Subway (Subway Sandwich Shop)4,0286.1%
Jimmy John’s7595.9%
Great Clips5145.3%
Sports Clips4444.5%

What the spread means

Matco Tools at 34.8% and Sports Clips at 4.5% are both franchises. One in three Matco borrowers did not repay; fewer than one in twenty Sports Clips borrowers failed to. That is a 7.7-fold difference, and it dwarfs anything attributable to franchising itself.

The pattern is not random. The worst performers cluster in food service and in models requiring significant inventory or equipment purchased from the franchisor. The best cluster in services with low fixed costs and recurring local demand — hair, cleaning, restoration.

Franchisors publish Item 19 financial performance representations. As far as we can find, nobody publishes what happens to the people who borrowed to buy in.

Method, and its limits

  • Computed from the complete public SBA 7(a) loan record, fiscal years 1992 to 2026, comprising 1,912,539 loans.
  • Charge-off rate is charged-off loans as a share of resolved loans. Loans still outstanding are excluded, because their outcome is unknown.
  • Minimum 400 resolved loans per brand, so small samples cannot distort the ranking.
  • Brand names in the source data are not consistently formatted. The same brand appears under multiple spellings, with and without trailing whitespace and in different cases. We normalise before aggregating. Where the SBA records genuinely distinct franchise codes for related programmes, those remain separate rows.
  • These are historical outcomes across three decades. They describe what happened to past borrowers, not a forecast for any current franchise offering.
  • Charge-off reflects the loan, not the business. A business can survive a charge-off and a business can close having repaid in full.
Correction, 24 August 2026. An earlier version of this page gave Jimmy John’s at 5.1% and stated the range as 5.1% to 34.8%. On review we found brand names in the source data were not normalised, so the same brand was being split across multiple spellings. After normalising, Jimmy John’s is 5.9% across 759 resolved loans and the range is 4.5% to 34.8%. Several brands missing from the earlier table have been added. The headline finding, that franchises charge off at 16.0% against 15.8% for independents, is unaffected because it does not depend on brand names.

Related: charge-off rates by state, SBA loan questions answered, and how to use this data.


Using this data

Free to use, including commercially, under CC BY 4.0. The aggregate tables are on GitHub as CSV. The underlying SBA file is public.

Cite as:

Edwards, P. (2026). SBA 7(a) Charge-Off Rates by Franchise Brand. Finance Clearly. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22132218

About the author. Logan R. Sterling writes Finance Clearly’s US coverage of retirement, small business lending and later-life costs.

General information, not financial advice. Figures are computed from public SBA data and describe historical outcomes for past borrowers, not any individual franchise opportunity.