The best fixed rate bonds are paying up to 5.00% AER. Premium Bonds pay a prize fund rate of 4.35% from the September 2026 draw. On the face of it the bond wins. Once tax is applied it often does not — and once you understand how the prize fund actually pays out, it sometimes does after all.
Here is the arithmetic, without the marketing from either side.
Where the rates stand
| Option | Rate | Taxable? |
|---|---|---|
| Best fixed rate bond | up to 5.00% AER | Yes |
| Best easy access | around 4.90% | Yes |
| Premium Bonds prize fund | 4.35% | No |
| Bank of England base rate | 3.75% | — |
What 5% is actually worth after tax
Interest is taxed at your marginal rate once you exceed the personal savings allowance. Premium Bond prizes are not taxed at all.
| Your position | 5% bond, after tax | Premium Bonds |
|---|---|---|
| Within your savings allowance | 5.00% | 4.35% |
| Basic rate, allowance used up | 4.00% | 4.35% |
| Higher rate, allowance used up | 3.00% | 4.35% |
| Additional rate (no allowance) | 2.75% | 4.35% |
So for anyone who has used up their personal savings allowance, a tax-free 4.35% beats a taxable 5%. For a higher-rate taxpayer it is not close.
The catch nobody explains properly
4.35% is not a return. It is the size of the prize fund divided by the money in it. That is a mean, and the prize distribution is heavily skewed by a small number of very large prizes.
Most holders receive less than the headline rate, because the £1m prizes and the other large ones pull the average up while the typical holder wins £25 prizes or nothing at all. The median return sits below the mean, and the smaller your holding the wider that gap tends to be.
With a small holding you may win nothing for months. With the full £50,000 the outcome converges closer to the average, because you hold enough bonds for the odds to even out.
A fixed rate bond pays exactly what it says. No distribution, no luck.
The honest comparison
- You have not used your savings allowance: the fixed bond wins outright. 5% effectively tax-free beats 4.35%.
- You pay higher-rate tax and have used your allowance: Premium Bonds are ahead on the mean, and the gap is wide enough that below-average luck still leaves you competitive.
- You might need the money: Premium Bonds can be cashed in within a few days. A fixed bond locks you in, usually with no early access at all.
- You have not used your ISA allowance: consider that first. £20,000 in a cash ISA, tax-free and with no luck involved, is usually a better answer than either.
- You want certainty: the bond. Premium Bonds are a lottery with your capital protected, not a savings rate.
Two things worth knowing
Both are safe, differently. Premium Bonds are backed by HM Treasury with no upper limit on protection. Fixed rate bonds are covered by the FSCS to £120,000 per person per banking licence, raised from £85,000 in December 2025. Check the licence rather than the brand — several savings brands share one.
Rates are falling. Base rate is 3.75% and the direction of travel has been downward. That is an argument for fixing now if you intend to fix, and it also means the Premium Bonds prize fund rate may be cut again.
Related: Premium Bonds versus a cash ISA, tax on savings interest, and all 2026/27 rates and allowances.
The 30-year gilt hit 5.89% on 1 September, a 28-year high — good for annuities, bad for bond funds and fixed mortgage rates.
About the author. Peter Edwards ACMA CGMA is the founder of Finance Clearly. He qualified with the Chartered Institute of Management Accountants and has spent 25 years in corporate finance, most recently as a finance director.
General information, not financial advice, and Finance Clearly is not authorised or regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. We do not recommend products or receive commission. Savings rates change frequently — always confirm current rates before acting.