Checked after the Autumn Budget, 28 October 2026. Nothing on this page changed. Business Asset Disposal Relief stayed at 18% and dividend rates were left alone, so the break-even figures below still hold. The Budget did halve the Business Asset Disposal Relief lifetime limit from £1 million to £500,000, for disposals on or after 6 April 2027, which does not affect the reserve levels covered here but does matter if you have claimed the relief before. What the Budget actually announced, and what the lifetime limit cut costs.
Almost every guide tells you an MVL is worth it once your company holds more than £25,000. For a lot of directors that is now wrong. £25,000 is a statutory cut-off, not a break-even point — and Business Asset Disposal Relief rose to 18% in April 2026, which is higher than the 10.75% basic-rate dividend rate. If most of your distribution would sit in the basic-rate band, a strike-off can leave you thousands better off at £50,000 of reserves, let alone £30,000.
Work out which is actually cheaper for you
Runs in your browser. Nothing is sent anywhere.
2026/27 rates, England, Wales and Northern Ireland. Scottish income tax differs but CGT does not. Assumes one shareholder, enough BADR lifetime limit left, and no capital losses brought forward.
Where the £25,000 figure actually comes from
It is a statutory limit, not advice. When a company is struck off, distributions to shareholders keep capital treatment only up to £25,000 in total. Go a pound over and the whole distribution becomes income, taxed at dividend rates — not just the excess.
So £25,000 marks the point where a strike-off stops being tax-efficient in its own right. It says nothing about whether paying a liquidator £1,500 to £3,000 is worth it. Those are two different questions, and the guidance has collapsed them into one.
Why the old answer stopped working in April
The standard advice was written when Business Asset Disposal Relief charged 10%. Against dividend rates of 8.75% and 33.75%, an MVL won easily for almost anyone above the threshold.
BADR has risen twice since: to 14% in April 2025, and to 18% from 6 April 2026. The basic-rate dividend rate is 10.75%. So for a shareholder with room left in the basic-rate band, the MVL route now carries the higher tax rate — and the liquidator’s fee on top of it.
A fair number of pages still quote BADR at 10%. If you are reading advice that does, the arithmetic behind it is two rate rises out of date.
What the break-even actually looks like
It depends almost entirely on your other income, because that decides which dividend band the strike-off distribution falls into. Assuming a £2,000 liquidator fee and a BADR claim:
| Your other income | An MVL only wins above |
|---|---|
| No other income | £79,050 |
| £12,570 director’s salary | £61,346 |
| £30,000 | £36,796 |
| £50,270 or more (higher rate) | £25,001 — here the usual advice holds |
The director on a £12,570 salary is the common case for a small limited company. At £50,000 of reserves that director is around £2,000 better off striking the company off — while being told by every search result to pay for a liquidation.
What the choice does not turn on
Speed. A strike-off takes about three months. An MVL usually takes six to twelve. If you need the money out quickly that matters, but it is rarely worth thousands.
Tidiness. Both end with the company dissolved.
What it does turn on, besides the tax: a strike-off can be objected to by any creditor, and a company struck off with debts outstanding can be restored to the register afterwards — with the directors exposed. An MVL requires a sworn declaration of solvency and gives a clean, final answer. If there is any doubt the company can pay everything it owes, the comparison on this page does not apply at all — an insolvent company needs a creditors’ voluntary liquidation, and taking money out first can make a director personally liable.
Three things that change the answer
Whether you actually qualify for BADR. You need at least 5% of the shares and voting rights, you must have been an officer or employee, and the company must have been trading for two years before it stopped. Without BADR the capital rate is 18% or 24% depending on your band — which weakens the MVL case further for a basic-rate shareholder, and strengthens it for a higher-rate one.
Two shareholders rather than one. A couple each get their own annual exemption and their own basic-rate band, so splitting a distribution can change which route wins. The calculator above assumes a single shareholder.
Timing across tax years. Dividends taken before a strike-off can be spread over two tax years to use two basic-rate bands. An MVL distribution is usually a single capital event. On reserves near the break-even this alone can decide it.
The anti-avoidance rule to know about
You cannot close a company, take the reserves as capital, and start a similar business shortly afterwards. The Targeted Anti-Avoidance Rule treats the distribution as income if you carry on a similar trade within two years and one of the main purposes was to reduce tax.
It applies to MVL distributions as much as to strike-offs, and it catches people who close one company and contract through another doing much the same work.
Still owe the company money on a director’s loan? That has to be cleared before either route — see the s455 calculator for what each way of clearing it costs.
Want these figures emailed to you?
Your break-even figure, and what the strike-off and MVL routes would each cost on your numbers. We will send the cheat sheet that goes with it. No sign-up wall, and you can unsubscribe from the first email.
Want the numbers checked against your actual position? The answer moves with your other income, your shareholding and your timing, and near the break-even it can go either way. Insight Professional Partners is the regulated accountancy practice run by Finance Clearly’s founder, a chartered management accountant, and can work the comparison through with you. An MVL itself must be handled by a licensed insolvency practitioner — we are not one, and we will say so rather than sell you one.
About the author. Written for Finance Clearly by Peter Edwards, a chartered management accountant. Rates checked against the 2026/27 figures. Reviewed October 2026.
General information, not tax advice. Figures assume one shareholder, sufficient BADR lifetime limit and no brought-forward losses. Closing a company is irreversible and the right route depends on your full position — take advice before acting.