How Far Back Can HMRC Investigate?

Four years for an innocent mistake, six years if HMRC considers the error careless, and twenty years where it considers the behaviour deliberate. Which window applies is decided by HMRC’s view of your behaviour, not by the size of the error.

The three time limits

HMRC’s view of the behaviourHow far back
Innocent error, reasonable care taken4 years
Careless — you did not take reasonable care6 years
Deliberate — you knew and did it anyway20 years

The same limits apply across income tax, corporation tax, VAT and PAYE. The four years runs from the end of the relevant tax year or accounting period.

The word that decides everything is “careless”

Four years to six years is a large jump, and it turns on a judgement rather than a fact. HMRC decides whether you took reasonable care.

In practice, keeping proper records, using an accountant, and correcting errors as soon as you find them all support the reasonable-care position. Repeated similar errors, missing records, or ignoring something you had been told about point the other way.

Why record retention and investigation windows do not match

You must keep records for five or six years. HMRC can investigate deliberate behaviour for twenty. That gap is deliberate on their part, not an oversight. If an enquiry reaches back further than your records, the absence of evidence works against you rather than for you.

What triggers an enquiry

  • Figures that sit outside the norm for your sector. HMRC compares returns against industry benchmarks.
  • Sudden changes. Turnover or margin moving sharply without an obvious reason.
  • Third-party data. HMRC receives information from banks, platforms, Land Registry and overseas tax authorities under exchange agreements.
  • Persistent late filing. It signals disorganisation, which correlates with error.
  • Random selection. A proportion of enquiries are genuinely random, so being selected does not mean you are suspected of anything.

If you receive an enquiry letter

  • Check what type it is. An aspect enquiry examines one item; a full enquiry examines the whole return. The letter says which.
  • Note the deadline and reply within it. Usually 30 days, and extensions are normally granted if you ask before it expires.
  • Give what is asked for, not more. Volunteering unrelated material widens the enquiry.
  • Get professional help early if the amounts are significant or if the letter mentions deliberate behaviour. The behaviour finding drives both the time limit and the penalty.

Disclosing before they ask

An unprompted disclosure attracts substantially lower penalties than one made after HMRC opens an enquiry. For a careless error the penalty range can fall to nil on an unprompted disclosure, against up to 30% if prompted.

If you know something is wrong, the arithmetic strongly favours telling them first.

Related: how long to keep business records, missing the Self Assessment deadline, and Self Assessment deadlines.


Want someone to look at it properly?

Insight Professional Partners is the accountancy practice run by this site’s author, a CIMA Member in Practice. The free bookkeeping health check tells you what an accountant would find in your books, at no cost and no obligation.

Got a letter? What each HMRC letter means — find the reference code and you know what you have.

Paid late? HMRC charges 7.75% interest — daily from the due date, and separate from penalties.

Stopped trading? How to tell HMRC you have ceased — and why stopping quietly costs money.

About the author. Peter Edwards ACMA CGMA is the founder of Finance Clearly. He qualified with the Chartered Institute of Management Accountants and has spent 25 years in corporate finance, most recently as a finance director.

General information, not tax advice. If you have received an enquiry letter involving significant sums or any suggestion of deliberate behaviour, take professional advice before responding.